OFFROAD.GUIDEBuilt your way. No haggling.
Four-wheel-drive vehicles on the wide dry sand of the Carova 4x4 beach.

Our method · Updated November 2026

The Beach 4x4 Score,
explained

A score for one question: which trim of this 4x4 should you buy if you plan to drive on the beach? We score each model against itself, from the street 4x4 trim up to the most extreme off-road trim, using published specs and the fixed rubric below. Written by Beach 4x4, 6+ years renting four-wheel-drive vehicles on the Outer Banks.

Why a ladder

We score each 4x4 against itself

Every truck and SUV we cover is a real 4x4, and most of them would do fine on an Outer Banks beach. Ranking a Bronco against a Tacoma tells you more about taste than about fit. So we don't rank brands against each other.

Instead, each model gets a ladder: its street 4x4 trim at the bottom, then its mid off-road trim, then its most extreme off-road trim. Every rung is scored with the same rubric, so you can see what the extra money buys on the sand and what it costs you the other 360 days of the year.

The trim with the best overall score gets the Beach 4x4 Pick badge. The trim with the highest sand and snow score gets Most capable. Often they are not the same truck, and that is the point.

Five categories

Sand and snow counts three times

Each category is scored out of 10 and rounded to one decimal. The overall score is the weighted average of those rounded numbers: (3 × sand and snow + daily + hauling + simple + price) ÷ 7, rounded to one decimal.

How the overall score is built
CategoryWeightWhat it measures
Sand and snow3×Hardware that keeps you moving in soft sand and snow
Daily driving1×Fuel use, tire noise and how easy it is to climb in
Family hauling1×Payload and towing
Keep it simple1×Parts that cost more to replace or maintain
Price1×Price with destination, against the cheapest rung on the same ladder

The rubric

Every point, in plain view

We score only what a manufacturer publishes or the EPA rates, so anyone can check the math. Prices include destination, for each trim as it comes with no option packages, and towing is scored at that standard rating. When a new model year has not published a spec yet, we use the prior year and say so on the ladder.

Sand and snow: raw points (12 possible), then ÷ 12 × 10
SpecPointsWhy it matters on the beach
Four-wheel drive2 (base)Every truck on a ladder has it; this is the floor
Two-speed transfer case (low range)2Low range gets you out of soft spots and up steep cuts slowly
Rear locker2 (limited-slip: 1)Keeps both rear tires pulling when one sinks or lifts
Tire typeAll-terrain 2 · mud-terrain 1.5 · all-season 0.5All-terrains float well aired down and stay quiet; mud-terrains dig more
Tire about 32 in. or taller1A taller tire has a longer footprint when aired down. We count 31.5 in. or more by the sidewall math, since a tire sold as a 32 often measures 31.6
Ground clearance10 in.+ 2 · 9–9.9 1.5 · 8–8.9 1 · under 8 0.5Deep ruts near the ramps and dune crossings
Published approach angle 30° or more1The front bumper and air dam clear ramp lips. No published number, no point

What earns nothing: a front locker. It helps on rocks, but on sand it makes steering heavy and we almost never need it. It costs a point under Keep it simple instead.

Daily driving: points add to 10
SpecPoints
EPA combined mpg20+ 4 · 19 3.5 · 18 3 · 17 2.5 · 16 or less 2
Tire noise (by tire type)All-season 3 · all-terrain 2 · mud-terrain 1
Easy in and outNo lift 3 · about 2 in. of lift 2.5 · 3 in. or more 2
Family hauling: points add to 10
SpecPoints
Payload1,600 lb+ 5 · 1,400–1,599 4 · 1,200–1,399 3 · under 1,200 2
Towing7,000 lb+ 5 · 6,000–6,999 4 · 5,000–5,999 3 · under 5,000 2
Price
RulePoints
Cheapest rung on the ladder10
Every $2,500 above the cheapest rung−1

What it leaves out

What the score doesn't measure

  • Reliability. There is no fair published number for a new model year.
  • Ride, seats and cabin feel. Those are worth a drive, not a score.
  • Rock crawling and water. We score for sand, snow and dirt roads. That is why front lockers and sway bar disconnects earn nothing here.
  • Brand against brand. Each ladder stands on its own. A 9 on one model's ladder doesn't mean it beats an 8 on another's.

Published ladders

Scores so far

More ladders are on the way, model by model.

Questions

About the score

Is the Beach 4x4 Score paid for by a brand or dealer?

No. The rubric is fixed and published on this page, and every number comes from the manufacturer's published specs or the EPA. A brand can't buy a better score.

Why does the most expensive trim often not win?

Because extreme trims add parts the beach doesn't need, like front lockers, bypass shocks and big mud-terrain tires, and they cost more to buy, run and repair. The score counts sand and snow three times, but it still counts the rest of your year.

Why is sand and snow weighted three times?

Because that is the reason to buy a 4x4 trim over the street version. The other four categories keep the score honest about what you give up to get it.

Can I compare scores across different models?

Not directly. Each ladder is scored against its own cheapest rung for price, so the scores are built to compare trims of one model.

What tire pressure do you assume on the beach?

18–20 psi for SUVs and half-ton pickups. Three-quarter-ton and heavier pickups keep 18–20 in the rear but run more up front: 22–25 psi with gas, 25–28 with a diesel. The score doesn't change with pressure; it scores the hardware.

How often are scores updated?

When a manufacturer publishes new specs or prices for a model year. Each ladder lists the model year of its data.

OffRoad.guide · Open all year

Half a day on the sand. Then the price, in writing.

Request your date

$325 a vehicle for the full five and a half hours, any month of the year. Request a date on the main page to get first pick. We email you to confirm it, with the booking link and the online license and insurance check. Questions? Email hello@offroad.guide; answers come back the same day.

How it works

Keys at the Hilton Garden Inn in Kitty Hawk, half a day up North Carolina Highway 12 and the Carova 4x4 beach, your family along and no salesperson. Then the No-Haggle Price in writing. The whole experience, start to finish.

Shopping with someone?

Send them this page.